What is a critique?
A critique is a genre of academic writing that briefly summarises and critically evaluates a work or concept. Critiques can be used to carefully analyse a variety of works such as:
- Creative works – novels, exhibits, film, images, poetry
- Research – monographs, journal articles, systematic reviews, theories
- Media – news reports, feature articles
Like an essay, a critique uses a formal, academic writing style and has a clear structure, that is, an introduction, body and conclusion. However, the body of a critique includes a summary of the work and a detailed evaluation. The purpose of an evaluation is to gauge the usefulness or impact of a work in a particular field.
Why do we write critiques?
Writing a critique on a work helps us to develop:
- A knowledge of the work’s subject area or related works.
- An understanding of the work’s purpose, intended audience, development of argument, structure of evidence or creative style.
- A recognition of the strengths and weaknesses of the work.
How to write a critique
Before you start writing, it is important to have a thorough understanding of the work that will be critiqued.
- Study the work under discussion.
- Make notes on key parts of the work.
- Develop an understanding of the main argument or purpose being expressed in the work.
- Consider how the work relates to a broader issue or context.
There are a variety of ways to structure a critique. You should always check your unit materials or blackboard site for guidance from your lecturer. The following template, which showcases the main features of a critique, is provided as one example.
Typically, the introduction is short (less than 10% of the word length) and you should:
- Name the work being reviewed as well as the date it was created and the name of the author/creator.
- Describe the main argument or purpose of the work.
- Explain the context in which the work was created. This could include the social or political context, the place of the work in a creative or academic tradition, or the relationship between the work and the creator’s life experience.
- Have a concluding sentence that signposts what your evaluation of the work will be. For instance, it may indicate whether it is a positive, negative, or mixed evaluation.
Briefly summarise the main points and objectively describe how the creator portrays these by using techniques, styles, media, characters or symbols. This summary should not be the focus of the critique and is usually shorter than the critical evaluation.
This section should give a systematic and detailed assessment of the different elements of the work, evaluating how well the creator was able to achieve the purpose through these. For example: you would assess the plot structure, characterisation and setting of a novel; an assessment of a painting would look at composition, brush strokes, colour and light; a critique of a research project would look at subject selection, design of the experiment, analysis of data and conclusions.
A critical evaluation does not simply highlight negative impressions. It should deconstruct the work and identify both strengths and weaknesses. It should examine the work and evaluate its success, in light of its purpose.
Examples of key critical questions that could help your assessment include:
- Who is the creator? Is the work presented objectively or subjectively?
- What are the aims of the work? Were the aims achieved?
- What techniques, styles, media were used in the work? Are they effective in portraying the purpose?
- What assumptions underlie the work? Do they affect its validity?
- What types of evidence or persuasion are used? Has evidence been interpreted fairly?
- How is the work structured? Does it favour a particular interpretation or point of view? Is it effective?
- Does the work enhance understanding of key ideas or theories? Does the work engage (or fail to engage) with key concepts or other works in its discipline?
This evaluation is written in formal academic style and logically presented. Group and order your ideas into paragraphs. Start with the broad impressions first and then move into the details of the technical elements. For shorter critiques, you may discuss the strengths of the works, and then the weaknesses. In longer critiques, you may wish to discuss the positive and negative of each key critical question in individual paragraphs.
To support the evaluation, provide evidence from the work itself, such as a quote or example, and you should also cite evidence from related sources. Explain how this evidence supports your evaluation of the work.
This is usually a very brief paragraph, which includes:
- A statement indicating the overall evaluation of the work
- A summary of the key reasons, identified during the critical evaluation, why this evaluation was formed.
- In some circumstances, recommendations for improvement on the work may be appropriate.
Include all resources cited in your critique. Check with your lecturer/tutor for which referencing style to use.
Checklist for a critique
- Mentioned the name of the work, the date of its creation and the name of the creator?
- Accurately summarised the work being critiqued?
- Mainly focused on the critical evaluation of the work?
- Systematically outlined an evaluation of each element of the work to achieve the overall purpose?
- used evidence, from the work itself as well as other sources, to back and illustrate my assessment of elements of of the work?
- formed an overall evaluation of the work, based on critical reading?
- used a well structured introduction, body and conclusion?
- used correct grammar, spelling and punctuation; clear presentation; and appropriate referencing style?
University of New South Wales - some general criteria for evaluating works
University of Toronto - The book review or article critique
- Grace Virtue´s Genre, Organization Structure, and Stylistic Features
- The French Genre of Reverie
- The Horror Genre in I am Legend by Richard Matheson
- The Hours - Film Analysis
- Masculinity in Film: The Incredibles
- Film Review: Shrek
- Narrated Short Film Instructions
- The Romantic Notion of a Film Director
- Narrative and Genre in I Robot
- Film Summary: 'Wit'
- Roman Holiday Film Review
- The Namesake Film Analysis
- History of Music in Horror Films
- Analysis of the Use of Film Trailers and Film Posters
- The Portrayal of the Gangster Genre in American and British Cinema in 'Goodfellas' by Martin Scorcese and 'Layer Cake' by Matthew Vaughn
- The Genre of Stoker's Dracula
- Bildungsroman, Literary Genre
- How Terminator Two Satisfies the Science Fiction Genre
- The 1941 Film, Citizen Kane,
- Business Proposal for Marathi Films
- The Gothic Genre and What it Entails
- Soap Opera Genre
- Hollywood Propaganda: The Glorification of War by the Film Industry
- Film Trailer Portfolio
- Bmw Films: Case Study
- How McCabe and Mrs Miller and Blade Runner Subvert Their Genres and Defy Audience Expectations
- Deadly Deception Documentary Film
- The Use of Narrative in Film
- Horror Films
- Film Analysis of Jaws
- Dancer in the Dark Film Review
- film journal 1
- Mary Shelley's Frankenstein Different Film Techniques
- Blacks In Film
- Film Autuerism
- Racism in Disney Films
- Music in Scorsese films
- Film Analysis on Blind Side
- The Cinematic Language of Film
- The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas: Personal Response to the Film and Novel
- Tyler Perry Films
- Taking a Look at Doubt, the Film
- Film Industry: Then And Now
- The Big Sleep, The Postman Always Rings Twice, and Gilda's Adherence to the Noir Genre
- Teachers Represented in Film
- Italian Film and Neorealism
- Film Industry in CIVET Countries
- Film The Piano
- Film Review of Lord of the Rings
- Portrayal of Latinos in Film
- How Does the Language in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein Reflect its Gothic Genre
- Why do Hindi films have a ‘Masala’ format?
- Analysis of Film The Matrix
- The Hays Code in Film Noir
- The Genre of The Tempest
- Film Analysis of Steven Spielberg's 'Schindler's List'
- Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hydes, The Horror Genre
- Fan Fiction: The Impact of a Fan-made Genre
- Valkyrie – A Film Review
- Analysis of Halloween Film Trailer
- what makes an excellent film
- Film: The Breakfast Club
- The History of Film, and the Film Industry Today
- Analysis of Western Film
- film crime
- Film "Stagecoach" Analysis
- Editing and Montage Film
- American Violence – a Critical Film Analysis of No Country for Old Men
- Taking a Look at Photographic Film
- Freud and Film
- The History of African Americans in Film
- Analyzing Film Trailers and Film Posters
- Witchcraft Portrayed in Films
- Film Analysis Story vs. Film - Curious Case of Benjamin Button
- L.a Confidential Film Noir
- India: One of the Leaders of the Film Production
- Important Concepts on Film Edition
- Red Tails: a Film Critique
- The Perception of Love in Romantic Films
- How the Novel Rebecca Reflects and Subverts the Conventions of the Romance Genre
- Hugo -a Film Report
- Trainspotting Film Analysis
- A Comparison of Film Techniques of Two Film Versions of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
- The Film Mulan
- Film Contributions of the Sixties
- Review of Film The World is Not Enough
- The Film of Nixon